Broadcasting, Music, Music Countdowns, Radio, Retro Rock

1971: Superb One Hit Wonders

Photo above by Julianne Woodson

Since the earliest days of rock and roll music during the 1950s, one hit wonders have always existed on Top 40 radio.  Artists who had one big hit and then faded into oblivion.

With this edition of my musical musings, I am concentrating on the superb “One hit wonders” of 1971.  I will be counting down the top songs in this category from 50 years ago.

What exactly is a “One Hit Wonder?” The basic definition: An artist has only one hit song during their career on the national Billboard Hot 100 pop chart. This music blog message pertains solely to hit songs within the United States.

 

Obviously, there some other rules that should be included if an artist is to be included for consideration as a one hit wonder.

  • No other songs from an artist ever peaking at number 41 or higher on the Billboard National Pop Chart.
  • One hit wonders vary from country to country. An artist may have just one hit in the United States but may have multiple hits in another country.
  • Regional hits are not taken into account: A second song must be a national hit and chart within the Billboard Top 40 pop survey.
  • Any song peaking outside of the Top 40, are always excluded for consideration.
  • Songs that peak from numbers 41 through 100 on the national Billboard Hot 100 pop chart are never considered as second hits.

The rule that a second song must be a Top 40 Billboard National pop chart hit was established in 1998, by music historian Wayne Jancik in his definitive work on the subject, “The Billboard Book of One-Hit Wonders.”

Photo of my 45 rpm single of “Here Comes the Sun” by Richie Havens. A record that I bought in the summer of 1971 and still own here in 2021.

The subject of “One hit wonders” has always been interesting to me and researching the reasons why some artists have only one hit song. Way before the advent of the Internet, my go to reference for this subject has been “The Billboard Book of Top 40 Hits” by Joel Whitburn. I consider Whitburn’s book to be the “bible” of Top 40 music reference and still proudly own a hard copy of this excellent book.

I grew up in Roanoke, Virginia and have fond memories listening to Top 40 radio in 1971.

During daylight hours, I would tune into a couple of Roanoke Valley stations:  WROV 1240 AM and WBLU 1480 AM. 

WROV was the top-rated radio station in Roanoke and the DJs that I remember during this time period were Bart Prater, Larry Bly, Jack Fisher, Dan Alexander, Ron Tompkins and Phil Beckman.

WROV Roanoke DJ Jack Fisher drinking milk at remote broadcast. Photo is courtesy of the WROV History Online Website/Pat Garrett.

At sundown, WROV reduced their power and WBLU signed off the air.  I would then listen to a variety of 50,000-watt clear channel AM stations at night.

The two main stations that I listened to during the nighttime were WLS 890 AM Chicago and WABC 770 AM New York. On the Big 89 WLS, Larry Lujack, Chuck Buell, Kris Erik Stevens and Scotty Brink were my favorite DJs. When listening to WABC, Dan Ingram and Cousin Brucie (Bruce Morrow) are the two radio DJ voices that I remember from 1971.

WLS Chicago Surveys from 1/18/71 and 8/23/71. Photo is courtesy of Pete Battistini: Author of the book, American Top 40 with Casey Kasem (The 1970’s).

On nights that WLS or WABC were hard to pick up, I had other clear channel stations for my listening pleasure. Among those other stations were, WOWO Fort Wayne 1190 AM, WCFL Chicago 1000 AM, CKLW Windsor, Ontario (Detroit) 800 AM, WKBW Buffalo 1520 AM and WKYC Cleveland 1100 AM.

At the end of 1971, Billboard Magazine published the top hits of the year. Below all the Top 10 hits from that year.  All artists listed on the year-end Top 10 chart had more than one hit during their careers.

1          “Joy to the World”      Three Dog Night

2          “Maggie May”/”Reason to Believe”   Rod Stewart

3          “It’s Too Late”/”I Feel the Earth Move”          Carole King

4          “One Bad Apple”         The Osmonds

5          “How Can You Mend a Broken Heart”           Bee Gees

6          “Indian Reservation (The Lament of the Cherokee Reservation Indian)”

               Paul Revere and the Raiders                               

7          “Go Away Little Girl”   Donny Osmond

8          “Take Me Home, Country Roads”      John Denver

9          “Just My Imagination (Running Away with Me)”     Temptations

10        “Knock Three Times”  Tony Orlando and Dawn 

Photo of my 45 rpm single that I bought in 1971 and still own today. “Cherish What Is Dear To You (While It’s Near To You” by Freda Payne. This artist is not a one hit wonder.

For the remainder of this message, I will be focusing on the musical year of 1971 and the numerous excellent one hit wonder songs during this golden year of Top 40 radio. 

Before I start my 1971 one hit wonders countdown, I will be sharing with you a band whom I thought only had 1 hit in America.  However, the Canadian group is a “Two Hit Wonder.”

“Sign, sign, everywhere a sign

Blockin’ out the scenery, breakin’ my mind

Do this, don’t do that, can’t you read the sign?”

True Confession:  Before I started writing this music blog message, I always assumed the song “Signs” by the Five Man Electrical Band as the best one hit wonder of 1971. However, that is erroneous information.  The Canadian rock group from Ottawa, Ontario had a second 1971 hit with “Absolutely Right” which peaked at number 26 on the Billboard Hot 100.

“Signs” peaked at number 3 on the Billboard Hot 100 and was the 24th biggest record for the entire year of 1971.  It’s an all-time favorite song for me and my selection as the best “Two Hit Wonder” from 50 years ago.

Besides the excellent song “Signs” and the Five Man Electrical Band, there are a few other “Two hit wonders” that I want to highlight on this message. Another Canadian band in this category are the Stampeders. Formed in Calgary, Alberta, the band reached number 8 with “Sweet City Woman.”  They had a second top 40 hit in America with, “Hit the Road Jack” during 1975.

Photos of 45 rpm singles that I own here in 2021: Both were two hit wonders. “Do You Know What I Mean” came from a jukebox, while “Sweet City Woman” is a single that I bought during the summer of 1971.

I also want to share a couple of other prominent “Two hit wonders” from 1971. American rock musician Lee Michaels hit the top 40 twice that year: “Do You Know What I Mean” reached number 6 and his follow up hit, “Can I Get a Witness” peaked at number 39. 

Welsh singer-songwriter and guitarist Dave Edmonds reached number 2 with “I Hear Your Knocking” during 1971. His song, “Slipping Away” peaked at number 39 during 1983 on the Billboard Hot 100.

Photo of my 45 rpm singles that I bought in 1971 and still own here in 2021. Both are one hit wonders.

As I evaluated the data from the Billboard Book of Top 40 Hits by Joel Whitman, there are two outlier songs that are technically one hit wonders:  But I refuse to place either of those artists and/or their songs in that category.

  • “Me and Bobby McGee” by Janis Joplin.  This posthumous number 1 song was Joplin’s only Top 40 hit.  She did have two other solo just outside of number 40: “Kozmic Blues” reached 41 and “Cry Baby” peaked at number 42. Joplin also reached number 12 in 1968 with “Piece of My Heart” with Big Brother & Holding Company. In my humble opinion, Ms. Joplin should never be considered a one hit wonder.
  • “Chicago” by Graham Nash.   Is this really a solo song or a band hit? Peaking at number 35 on the Billboard Hot 100, “Chicago” is found on two albums:  It was released first on the Crosby Stills Nash and Young’s, “4 Way Street” album during April 1971. Then one month later, it showed up on Graham Nash’s debut solo album, “Songs For Beginners.”  With Nash having multiple hits with the Hollies and CSN&Y, he doesn’t deserve the title or status as a one hit wonder artist.

Most of the true one hit wonders from 1971 are songs that I do not mind hearing 50 years later. However, there are a couple of novelty songs in this category that I never, ever want to hear again in my life:

  •  Chirpy Chirpy Cheep Cheep–Mac and Katie Kisson
  •  Chick-A-Boom (Don’t Ya Jes’ Love It)–Daddy Dewdrop

Before starting the countdown of my favorite Top 13 “one hit wonder” favorites, here are five singles that peaked between numbers 26 and 40:

  • I’d Love to Change the World—Ten Years After
  • Games—Redeye
  • Hallelujah—Sweat Hog
  • Resurrection Shuffle—Ashton, Gardner and Dyke
  • 1900 Yesterday—Liz Damon’s Orient Express

Now it is time for my countdown:  A baker’s dozen of what I consider to be the best one hit wonders of 1971:

13.   I’ve Found Someone on My Own—The Free Movement

Peak position on Billboard Charts:  #5 Hot 100, #7 AC

 The Free Movement was a soul/R&B ensemble from Los Angeles, California.  Their mellow soft rock hit was the 27th biggest record of 1971.

12.   Timothy—The Buoys

Peak Position on Billboard Charts:  #17 Hot 100:  87th biggest hit of 1971

Pop/rock band from the Wilkes-Barre-Scranton, Pennsylvania area. This controversial song written by Rupert Holmes, featured lyrics about a coal mine disaster and cannibalism. The message of the song was problematic. Nevertheless, it was still a hit.

11.    Get It On—Chase

Peak Position on Billboard Chart:  #24 Hot 100

Bill Chase formed a jazz-rock fusion band named after himself. The song “Get It On” sounds similar to what rock bands Chicago or Blood Sweat & Tears recorded during the early 70s.

10.    Funky Nassau—The Beginning of the End

Peak position on Billboard Charts:  #15 Hot 100, #7 R&B:  75th biggest hit of 1971

From Nassau, Bahamas, the Beginning of the End played a variety of musical genres:  A hybrid of Funk, R&B, Calypso, Latin, Jazz and Pop.  Band was known for their horn section.

9.      Mr. Big Stuff—Jean Knight

Peak position on Billboard Charts:  #1 R&B, #2 Hot 100:  17th biggest hit of 1971

A sassy, upbeat soul song, that has an excellent bass line. Jean Knight’s song was nominated for Best Female R&B Vocal Performance at the 1972 Grammy Awards.

8.      Here Comes the Sun—Richie Havens

Peak Position on Billboard Charts:  #16 Hot 100:  95th biggest hit of 1971

 1969 Woodstock singer-songwriter and guitarist Richie Havens performs a superb mid-tempo cover of this George Harrison song.  The combination of accompanied conga drum playing, along with Havens’ excellent guitar riffs, makes for an outstanding musical performance.

7.      Put Your Hand in the Hand—Ocean

Peak Position on Billboard Charts: #2 Hot 100:  33rd Biggest Hit of 1971

Originally recorded by Anne Murray, the Canadian band Ocean had an international smash with their gospel song.  “Put Your Hand in the Hand” has been covered by many artists over the years, including by Elvis Presley, Loretta Lynn, Lynn Anderson, Joan Baez and Randy Stonehill. The song was inducted into the Canadian Songwriters Hall of Fame in 2006.

6.      One Toke Over the Line—Brewer and Shipley

Peak Positions on Billboard Charts: #10 Hot 100:  63rd Biggest Hit of 1971

American folk rock duo Brewer & Shipley had a contentious hit song during 1971, with lyrics mentioning Jesus and drug usage. According to Wikipedia: “U.S. Vice President Spiro Agnew, tried to get the FCC to ban the song on American radio.”  Obviously, Agnew wasn’t successful banning “One Tote Over the Line” and it can still be heard on U.S. radio here in 2021.

5.      Toast and Marmalade for Tea—Tin Tin

Peak Position on Billboard Chart:  #20 Hot 100

Maurice Gibb of the Bee Gees produced the only hit for the Australian rock band.  Tin Tin’s song features tight harmonies and starts off with a distinctive piano melody. The tune then builds by adding multiple guitars, bass, drums, brass and stringed instruments, making a pleasing crescendo at the end of the song.

4.       Rings—Cymarron

Peak Position on Billboard Charts:  #17 Hot 100, #6 AC

Cymarron was a band out of Memphis, Tennessee and they named their band after a 60’s TV show called, “Cimarron Strip.”  Lyrics to the song mentions listening to “James Taylor on the stereo” and is considered a quintessential soft rock tune of the early 70s. Tompall & the Glaser Brothers recorded a cover version of “Rings” and it reached number 7 on the Billboard County Singles Chart.  Their rendition mentions listening to “Merle Haggard on the stereo.”

3.       Woodstock—Matthews Southern Comfort

Peak Positions on Billboard Charts:  #23 Hot 100

A song that Joni Mitchell wrote during 1969, “Woodstock” had already been a hit for Crosby Stills Nash & Young during the Spring of 1970. British country folk/rock band Matthews Southern Comfort recorded another cover of Mitchell’s anthem, and their version became a hit in 1971.  This newer version of the song featured a slower tempo and had a country/rock vibe.  Ironically, Ian Matthews left his own band before “Woodstock” became a hit in America.

2.       Wedding Song (There is Love)—Paul Stookey

Peak positions on Billboard Charts:  #3 AC, #24 Hot 100:  92nd biggest hit of 1971

Noel Paul Stookey first gain musical popularity with the folk-rock trio Peter, Paul and Mary in 1961.  Their group broke up for the first time during 1970 and Stookey’s only solo hit came the following year.  “Wedding Song (There is Love)” became a popular song played at weddings during the 70s and the tune is still performed at some marriage ceremonies nearly 50 years later.

  1.   Smiling Faces Sometimes—The Undisputed Truth

Peak Positions on Billboard Charts:  #2 R&B, #3 Hot 100:  14th biggest hit of 1971

The Undisputed Truth was a psychedelic soul/R&B Motown trio consisting of Joe Harris, Billie Calvin and Brenda Evans. The lyrics of the song are about “back stabbing” friends and the consequences of those actions.  The Funk Brothers session band provides outstanding musicianship and the trio maintains excellent harmonies on this melodic tune. Without a doubt, “Smiling Faces Sometimes” is my favorite one hit wonder from 1971.

Now that I have humbly submitted my thoughts on “one hit wonders” of 1971, I am curious to find out your opinion on the music from that year.

Obviously, I do not want to come across as authoritative with my critique of the “one hit wonder” songs from 1971. The songs that you might feel are the best, maybe be completely different from my selections.

So I am asking for your opinion: What do you consider to be the best “one hit wonders” of 50 years ago? There are no right or wrong answers. I welcome your thoughts.

Listening to music from the golden age of Top 40 radio will always have a special place in my heart.  I cherish and fondly remember my favorite “one hit wonders” of 1971.  Rock on!

To subscribe to my blog via email, please click the “Follow” button in the menu above.

Standard

15 thoughts on “1971: Superb One Hit Wonders

  1. pwfariss@cox.net says:

    Thanx Dave. Really enjoyed. May have to go wit “The Wedding Song’’ for it’s continual impact thruput the years. Also really liked “Signs” . Great Blog as always!!!

  2. sueceezee says:

    I gotta agree with Signs and Sweet City Woman as one plus hit wonders and with Janis and Graham as outstanding hit makers. 10 Years After, Mr. Big Stuff, Get It On, One Toke Over the Line, and Smiling Faces make me happy. Even though I was a giddy 22-year-old in 1971, I can’t stand sad, sentimental, or sappy songs now. Time changes a person.

  3. drdavedelaney says:

    Fascinating topic as always, and – as usual – it sent me down a real rabbit trail! haha! But this is a hard category given the parameters and the artists that would be thereby included – Janis Joplin? Graham Nash? Richie Havens? Dave Edmunds? I wouldn’t list those names. We’d also have to include “Runt,” Todd Rundgren’s old band and their only hit “We Got To Get You a Woman” from 1971. I also couldn’t include Isaac Hayes, even though I think “Shaft” in 1971 was really his only hit or Nitty Gritty Dirt Band, although I think that “Mr. Bojangles” (1971) was also their only real hit. So no, I don’t think any of them count. For me, part of the ingredient of a one-hit-wonder is nobody remembers them – people just know this one song – and when you do a “where are they now?” on them you find they ended up selling insurance or doing Nobel level research or something. Having said that, I’m having trouble thinking of any of these (or the others from my own culling of the top 200) that are *truly* one hit wonders that I’d put on a “great memories of this song” list. But … I’ll offer three from 1971 that I think are perhaps the most memorable for me: “Signs” (5-Man), “Me and You and a Dog Named Boo” (Lobo), and Lee Michaels “Do You Know What I Mean” – honorable mentions: Sammi Smith “Help Me Make It Through the Night” for how awkwardly it was performed by other artists, The Bells “Stay Awhile” for borderline creepiness, and “Timothy” (The Buoys) for being utterly unsettling (based on a true story, they told us at the time).

  4. Bernard Johnson says:

    Nicely put together. My Favorite One Hit Wonder of 71 would be “Smiling Faces” – Undisputed Truth. I’ve remembered that phrase and is still true today.

  5. David H says:

    Great reading! I had never heard a few of these. My favorite would have to be Woodstock by Matthews Southern Comfort. Always loved their mellow cover.

  6. Sherry Richardson says:

    Love this feature. As always, David, very entertaining and thought provoking. It really got those wheels turning in my mind, I’ve treasured many one hit wonders in my time, but from 1971, I would have to pick Smiling Faces as my favorite.

  7. Barb Rudolph says:

    Some of these I either don’t know, or don’t remember, and some I don’t like — but unqualified approval for your #1 pick! Smiling Faces (Sometimes) was great then, and has definitely stood the test of time.

  8. Mark says:

    I was born in 1960, so 1971 was one of my early music loving years. Nevertheless your post brings back memories, even though I reckon I only know 2 of the 13 favourites you listed (bear in mind I live in Australia, so I’m not sure how many actually got airplay/charted here).

    But I’ll offer some feedback over a couple of posts.
    “Chicago”
    I’m a big Sherbet fan (Aussie group who should have cracked the US charts, but only made #61 with both Howzat in 1976 & I Have The Skill – as the Sherbs – in 1981). In 1973 for their On With The Show album they turned Nash’s song into an 11 minute epic. Here’s a live performance.

    “Chirpy Chirpy Cheep Cheep”
    Firstly, I’m not sure I’d agree that it was a novelty song, it’s been interpreted as being about child abandonment.
    It was interesting because it had three versions around this time. The original, by Lally Stott, hit #1 here in Australia and top 10 in South Africa.
    The biggest version was by Middle of the Road, who had a huge hit with it in Europe (it went #2 again here in Australia).
    But for some reason it was the Mac & Katie Kissoon version which charted in North America.

    Cheers, Mark.

  9. Darlene Richardson says:

    IMHO, 1971 is when music started to diverge into so many different forms and that experimentation did not always lead to good results. You listed quite a few songs that I don’t remember, but “Timothy,” “One Toke Over The Line,” and “Put Your Hand in the Hand” stood out because they were played to death on the radio. My favorites “one hit wonders” for 1971 would be “The Wedding Song” by Paul Stookey, “One Tin Soldier” theme song for the movie “Billy Jack” by Original Caste, and “American Pie,” by Don McLean. Great job, Dave!

  10. David Randall Hardie says:

    DW another excellent blog. Out of your Baker’s Dozen I will pick 4. I have to admit I had forgotten many of them and had to go to YouTube to try and recall them.
    #1 Smiling Faces #2 Wedding Song #3 Mr. Big Stuff and #4 Toast and Marmalade for Tea. #4 is mainly for sentimentality. On a Friday night me and 4 other buddies had gotten someone to buy us some beer (names are protected due to statute of limitations). We did have a DD that night (not me). Sitting out on a loading dock sipping a few cold ones, someone started singing Toast and Marmalade and we giggled and giggled like 16 year olds will do. Never have forgotten that song. So thank you for bringing back that memory.

  11. Laurie Russell says:

    Excellent blog (as always). Many of the songs you listed I do not even remember, but two do stand out for me. Put Your Hand in the Hand and One Toke Over the Line are two songs I remember well and still enjoy listening to today. These are definitely my top choices for One Hit Wonders!

  12. Carlo Marinuzzi Jr says:

    3 songs that year for me, may not have been top 40 smashes, but they were big with me, all of which were in my top 50 that year. 13 QUESTIONS-SEATRAIN, FRESH AS A DAISY-EMITT RHODES and IT’S FOR YOU-SPRINGWELL.

  13. Pingback: 1969: Best One Hit Wonders | DJ Dave's Musical Musings

Leave a Reply to Mark Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s